Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Player Restrictions/Ejections, Playing Shorthanded

Question: A team can start/play shorthanded (one less than required/starting). If a team doesn't have a substitute to replace a player that has been ejected, the game is forfeited since the shorthanded rule does not apply here.
The question is on restrictions to bench -
I believe a restriction is equal to an ejection. If a team doesn't have a substitute to the restricted player the game is forfeited. The Umpire enforced a rule/penalty and therefore if the team can not replace the restricted player, the game is over. They cannot use the shorthanded rule and take an out.
Am I correct on this ruling?

Answer: The rule is written as just ejection. The philosophy is that ejection is the penalty for the worst actions (fighting, ..) and that restriction to the bench is slightly lesser.
We could debate whether it should be that way and which actions should fall in which category but that is the intent.
So if a player is restricted to the bench, the team can continue shorthanded.

metal toe plates

Question: Rule 2 Section 4 Shoes: In all divisions 14 and under and younger, Metal cleats and metal toe plates are prohibited. This is understandable. However, in divisions which metal cleats are allowed the toe plate must be securely fastened. Last year 15U and older were allowed metal cleats and toe plates.
In this years Clarification & Interpretation Topics Version 5, page 27, Pitcher's Uniform - A pitcher may not wear a metal toe plate on her shoe.
This appears to be inconsistent with the rule.

Answer: Unfortunately I just forgot to update the Clarification & Interpretation last year when we change the metal cleat/toe plate rule.
In any inconsistency the Rule Book takes precedence.